For more than four decades researchers have been interested in learning what happens to gifted students who drop out of high school. Estimates of the number of gifted learners who drop out differ widely, and a figure of 20 percent is often repeated despite the fact that there is little evidence to support it. Recent studies suggest that anywhere from 1 in 50 up to 1 in 200 academically gifted students fails to complete high school, depending on the criteria used to determine giftedness. Although dropping out of school remains relatively uncommon among academically gifted learners, clearly it is an important issue for those students who do.
Parents should also be aware that the increasing cognitive demands of high school curriculum might be a source of difficulty for students who previously may have experienced few, if any, academic challenges.
Findings from studies on gifted underachievement and general education dropouts can give us insights into the study of gifted dropouts. These studies suggest that ability, academic achievement, motivation, drug use, and school culture all can influence students’ dropout decisions. Since gifted students by definition possess strong academic abilities, would gifted learners who choose to leave school without a diploma report different reasons for their decision than general education students? With this question in mind, I began looking for gifted dropouts who were willing to share their stories and attempting to learn more about the seemingly contradictory phenomenon of highly able students failing to graduate from high school.
Through an initial and a follow-up interview, I have spoken so far with a half dozen gifted individuals who had dropped out of high school. These were five females and one male student, from four different states, ranging in age from 18 to 27. Two were Latina and the rest White.
Findings
Two themes related to individual differences appeared in the narratives of multiple participants. These included the following:
- When specifically questioned, a number of individuals noted a particular dislike of, or difficulty with, coursework in mathematics. These same individuals contended elsewhere in the same interview that they thought all subjects were easy (or non-challenging).
- In high school, some learners reported having relatively few close friends; they found that their age peers seemed to be concerned more with social interaction and less committed to learning or academic performance.
In addition, their schools’ organizational culture sometimes was not structured in a way that would keep these gifted learners enrolled.
- Gifted students who dropped out viewed their high school classes as ‘more of the same’ and indicated they would have preferred learning something new.
- Several students recalled a keenly felt realization of differences between the middle school and high school environments, which led to dissatisfaction with high school. In some cases a lack of gifted programming in high school made them no longer feel ‘special’ due to their gifted status, as they had in middle or elementary school.
- In one case, individualized educational options were only available to the student if she officially stated her intention to drop out.
- Students whose families frequently moved encountered repeated difficulties in transferring course credit across schools and were forced to repeat coursework they had completed elsewhere. Consistent with findings about dropouts in general education settings, family mobility was evident in most of the cases; few of the participants had remained in the same location throughout high school.
Parenting was discussed indirectly, because I was primarily curious to learn about school- and individual-level influences. In some cases parents apparently had offered little input about the student’s decision to drop out, while other parents actively supported the decision. Early family responsibilities affected two students. One participant at age 16 had entered what turned out to be an unsuccessful marriage as a means of escaping her unhappy home life; another was engaged at the age of 18. In both cases these responsibilities appear to have interfered with these young women’s education.
Most of those interviewed were completing a GED program or attending a four-year or community college, although not all had achieved success in college on their first try. For the two oldest respondents, one was completing a master’s degree, and the other had already obtained one. Notably, this oldest participant reported being satisfied with her non-traditional educational path. After dropping out at age 16, she completed a GED, a year of community college, a four-year degree, and a Master of Arts degree at a competitive public university by the time she turned 21. She noted that her classmates who had remained in high school were still undergraduates at the time she finished her master’s degree.
Implications for Parents
So, what can parents learn from these students’ experiences? It appears that some gifted learners may need extra help in mathematics, and all might benefit from parental assistance in coming to grips with the changing nature of curriculum between middle school, high school, and college. Help your children understand that during these school transitions, learning often progresses from a group-oriented approach in elementary school toward one that emphasizes individual performance in the higher grades. The approaches toward giftedness by schools change over time too, from a view that places emphasis on ability and potential in the early grades to one that takes into account prior academic achievements. Parents should also be aware that the increasing cognitive demands of high school curriculum might be a source of difficulty for students who previously may have experienced few, if any, academic challenges.
Several schools showed unwillingness to individualize educational plans and to offer flexible alternatives to traditional curricular tracks; these positions were at least partially responsible for some of these gifted learners’ decisions to drop out. This is consistent with other studies that have found a lack of acceleration or related curricular options available to most high-ability learners. The general lack of gifted education training and programming in secondary settings may also be partially responsible for these difficulties, as misconceptions abound about academic acceleration. Parents who desire to keep their children on track to a traditional high school diploma should strive to be aware of the regulations and options available at their child’s school and should carefully monitor their child’s progress toward this goal. Forming or joining a state or local advocacy organization (see sidebar) can be a great help in developing awareness of the experiences of other gifted students and parents in your local area.
Finally, parents should keep in mind that dropping out of high school is not the end of the world. The student’s education becomes a more winding path that is likely more difficult. Although it is not the traditional educational trajectory, in time, it still can lead to success in higher education and in life.
—Michael S. Matthews, PhD
Michael Matthews is an assistant professor in the gifted education program at the University of South Florida in Tampa.
Resources
“Gifted students who drop out: New evidence from a Southeastern state,” by M. S. Matthews, Roeper Review, 28, 2006, 216–223
“Factors that differentiate underachieving gifted students from high-achieving gifted students,” by D.B. McCoach and D. Siegle, Gifted Child Quarterly, 47(2), 2003, 144-154.
How to Parent so Children will Learn: Clear Strategies for Raising Happy, Achieving Children, by S. Rimm, Three Rivers, 1996
Hi, My name is Joshua Rose. I was in the midwest talent search program in 6th grade. My counselors unofficially put my I.Q. in the high 140s in 7th grade. I was very social and connected well with other students, half the time. The other half the time I would find myself stunned sometimes catatonic from existential questions that had haunted me since my very first memories and days of cognition. I came from a large family and my fear of them holding the same questions in developed an empathetic alignment of reflexive knowledge that gave me an aptitude for reading people. Alot of the time I’d find myself getting people lost using very colorful and emotion vocabulary and I would always know what their reaction would be. I dropped out…. well unofficially at 15 cause I had a realization that the curriculum wasnt doing anyone any good… it was good at pumping out humanity as a controllable resource. But all these childrens potential for real gifts and real importance was being smothered with psychological horror flavored angles of perception. Even the teachers gave me the proof I needed with the looks on their faces. Example: Why are the teachers not assigned a class to continue with through out there entire grade school experience… They wouldnt have to adopt apathy to deal with new faces of pointless numbers… that apathy turns into abuse…. i know im not the first to think about this… I have days and days of ideas thanks to my three significant others that would sit and listen to me talk…. well pretend to while they did other things…. I realized a thought is just one track playing with never changes… but when we speak we can play that track and listen to the information with an adaptive track playing in the background hooked up to our knowledge and feeling…. SOoOO I get off “track” easily…. Anyway I dropped out and joined my older brothers in construction (no this isnt a mat damon movie I hate math) I also played music and developed alot of Ideas that mainly had to do with raising children. I purposely never got my own place with the intention of the extra money being useful to my friends who had procreated young who always needed a babysitter which was perfect for what interested me… I had something like 35 “god children” by 27. Well when I finally had my own. I went from not having my own place to having three jobs and a beautiful apartment within 10 months… Heres a twist….. I have a strong mentality of peacefulness and hope for mankind… It comes from those questions I was born with stuck in my head. My childhood was a real nightmare and my teenage years were a real war. There are alot of things I don’t ever tell others anymore cause my friends would become uncomfortable and distance themselves. I woke up one time with my mother sitting on my chest hitting me in the face telling me to get out of her head… I was 22 at the time. Her and I had spoke earlier, well I spoke, about how thoughts had to have certain physical properties to exist and had to abide by certain laws of physics… She thought i was losing my mind… I laid in bed that night imagining talking to her in her dreams trying to show her why she could relax and be comfortable and know she had done so much for me and her other children and only nature could match in having the unpayable debt I and other men owe. We never spoke about what happened… and she is currently in a nursing home losing her grip. I havent seen her in almost three years… Anyway.. You can believe or just well do whatever you want. I dont know why Im even trying to reach out anymore… My story has always been more powerful than me. Im sure these are dellusions brought on by stress of poverty and my gifted mind gave them extra power over my reality…. Everyday of my life has been like that one story. lol. I love you whoever is reading this. I hope things get better. I really do…. Oh ya the reason I was writing was the fact that I had 6 children after 27 years of wanting nothing but to have a chance to see what childhood would be like if my parents really knew everything would be okay and could show us love without fear.. They took my children and couldnt admit they were impress and scared of me…. I havent seen them in years… people tell them Im a worthless lazy junky…. A hospital kicked me out 7 times while mrsa was eating my knee away…. I told them what was wrong the first time but they tried telling me it was just arthritis… My leg was 3 times its normal size and had so much heat it was obviosly infection… one they had diagnosed just a month earlier in my foot…i almost died…. Now I cant bend one of my legs. My mind as become so active and sharp due to not being able to be active or work. not even a steady diet of street opiates and meth and anything else out there can even make me feel anything else but the pain and anger that having my children and freedom taken away has caused.. So FUCK curriculum… If anyone even got to look at the world and decide for themselves how they thought shit worked and anyone can and should… Nothing wrong with guiding children but cutting down their potential is a crime against nature. And taking children away from their mothers and fathers is a crime against god…. and everyones comfort of reality and science is no longer a factor in our actions
Hello. I am the parent of an identified gifted person id in his late junior year of 2018, when He came to us stating he was suffering w severe depression. He. Graduated from high school this year and began college.
Just got a call yesterday that he just wants to come home. He is sick of classes that wastes his time and sick Of homework. Socially he said things are ok. Wants to leave now bc fears it will be more difficult if he stays (depression).
Any advise?
( I just came across your article by accident – or was it?)
Dear Ms. Colleran,
Your question is an important one, but one that is equally difficult to answer. There is definitely a loss to the individual and the society when a significant talent goes to waste, and that is a tragedy. When it comes to companies offering internships to students who have dropped out, I know of no company who, as a program or priority, does that. Circumstances such as these (the gifted individual who drops out of high school) occur too often, but there isn’t, to my knowledge, any kind of a program to address the needs of young adults in this situation. Were the student still enrolled in school and receiving services as an exceptional student with a disability, there is a requirement to develop a transition plan to prepare the student for post-secondary life; however this transition planning would occur only if the student is still enrolled in school. You mentioned physics specifically in the case of your person of interest. Using the (former) student’s area of strength to connect to an internship is a great idea, but physics is an area, while not exactly esoteric, is not a knowledge or skill base that readily transfers to just any employment/internship situation. It would be far more likely to be able to find an internship or employment through a more generalizable skill set. It may be more advantageous to engage the young adult in some manner of career counseling to determine the strengths and interest that provide something that would be appealing to a potential employer. However, as far as identifying specific companies that offer internships to gifted students who have dropped out of school, I am sorry to reply that I have no knowledge of any such programs or companies to suggest.
Cary, I have asked our resident expert Dr. Rick Courtright to weigh in with some advice. It may take a few days but stop back by soon and I hope we will have some words of advice for you… thanks, Katy Munger
I am not sure those statistics are available, but I have passed the question on to our Research team and will let you know what we hear back! – Katy Munger
Hi.
I was just wondering what the statistic was for Gifted kids who drop out, but go on to receive their Bachelors? And how many go on to earn a Doctorate degree?
What are options for an 18 year old that dropped out, but is gifted? I see articles on kids dropping out, but what a shame to not offer ways to live up to their potential. Are there companies that offer internships to these types of people? A kid slightly on autistic scale that is highly motivated toward physics may just not have been bothered to turn in any work that was of low interest.